Soviet-era myths about Winter War with Finland slow to dissipate
Kommentaarid on kirjutatud EWR lugejate poolt. Nende sisu ei pruugi ühtida EWR toimetuse seisukohtadega.
VanemadUuemad
Catastrophe17 Feb 2006 09:31
Even the pretense to scholarship has collapsed in the humanities departments of the contemporary university where an attempt to dispell some historical myths would be jeered at and, especially so, if it tarnished the image of the left.
Who is there to tend to the historical record and where can they work?
reader17 Feb 2006 12:51
Thank you, Paul Goble, your work is important and timely.
Anonymous17 Feb 2006 13:05
I agree with "reader" and always look forward to a contribution from Goble.

Anatoly Tsyganok sounds like someone we should get to know. Can anyone out there tell us a little about him?
Tiritamm18 Feb 2006 11:37
The comparative casualty statistics reflect the fact that life is cheap under totalitarianism and that Soviet military commanders employed combat tactics involving heavy sacraficial losses.

In Khrustchev's memoires, I recall mention of Soviet losses in the order of a million. I wonder if there is any consensus on this matter?
.19 Feb 2006 07:01
Life's become pretty cheap in the USA as well, with a huge part of the population unable to cover itself medically. Income levels are slowly slipping and quality of life is not what it used to be. Good scapegoat; let's find the problem beyond our own doorstep!
Anonymous19 Feb 2006 09:03
You can't disguise your style any more than someone else could imitate it. Why? Simply because the essence of your message is as confused as its delivery. You're like a woodpecker -- can't hide in the forest because of his beak.
Anonymous19 Feb 2006 09:04
Sorry, Maxim. I spelled your name wrong.
Novice19 Feb 2006 09:35
" - a scenario strikingly similar to the way in which Hitler's Gestapo attacked Poland only three months later".
Hitler attacked Poland on 1. September, 1939. Soviet Union attacked Finland on 30. November, 1939, (the Mainila provocation was a few days before that). Please, mr. Goble, what happened in Poland "three months later", at the end of February 1940, when the war between Germany and Poland was practically over?
Dear mr Goble - I thank you for the article and hope to get a reply.
to -- Novice/Maxim20 Feb 2006 07:00
Mr. Goble can't reply to this because it's incomprehensible.
Anonymous21 Feb 2006 06:56
I don't like the tone of your writing. It's much better and more interesting than mine. Who do you think you are anyway!
Kommentaarid sellele artiklile on suletud.
SÜNDMUSED LÄHIAJAL

Vaata veel ...

Lisa uus sündmus