No Russian could make a film about Putin like Oliver Stone's 'W' about Bush
Archived Articles 27 Oct 2008 Paul GobleEWR
    Trüki   E-post   FB     
VIENNA, October 23 – Oliver Stone's new movie "W" about the life and times of President George W. Bush has prompted Russians to ask whether any director in their country would dare make a similar film about Vladimir Putin. The answer most surveyed by one paper gave was a resounding "no" – unless of course the Russian leader gave his permission.

In fact, "Moskovsky komsomolets" reports, a film called "Kiss Not for the Press" appears to be about Putin – its lead, like Putin, is a chekist who loves judo, falls in love with a stewardess, works in St. Petersburg, and then goes to Moscow – but those involved in its production deny the link (www.mk.ru/blogs/MK/2008/10/20/....

The paper then asked several figures in the Russian film industry whether they would be willing to make a film about Putin in much the same way that Stone has done about the incumbent American president. Producer Sergey Selyanov said he would not be inclined to do so because "in Russia there have been still too few presidents."

In the future, such a film might be possible, but he continued, "it would be necessary to ask for the permission of the president himself." If the idea for a film of this kind was good, Selyanov said, he would be prepared to ask Putin for his clearance, but he noted that he personally "would never agree to the making a film about himself."

Another Russian film industry leader said that "in Russia there is no Oliver Stone;" there are only directors prepared to make "romantic" films about a judoist and a stewardess. If a Russian Stone appeared, the question would inevitably arise: Would he make money given the Russian audience or would be declared "a traitor to the Motherland" for what he had done?

And yet a third, Aleksandr Minkin, noted that "over the course of the entire history of the USSR and Russian Federation," there was only one leader – Boris Yeltsin – who was routinely criticized or made fun of in the public media. But now that period is "officially called 'the wild 1990s,'" and nothing like that is to be repeated.

Consequently, he told the Moscow newspaper, in thinking about what movies Russian producers and directors might make about Putin, it was better to think about Soviet filmmakers rather than people like Oliver Stone and to recognize that only certain kinds of heroic films would be acceptable. Among them, he said, might be the following:

• "Putin – Our Military Glory!" in which bearded mountaineers march along Putin Prospekt in the Chechen capital of Grozny;

• "Putin – Our Pride and Achievement" in which Putin is piloting a fighter plane and then serving as a bombardier; and

• "Working and Triumphing with Putin" in which Putin uses a jet to pursue the fleeing Georgian leader Mikhail Saakashvili. "

Of course, Minkin said, even these films might get their authors in trouble, and an all points bulletin could be put out by the authorities for their arrest.

The "Moskovsky komsomolets" article is especially interesting because it shows that Russians are reacting to Oliver Stone's move in a very different way than many Americans might expect. Instead of viewing it as one more piece of evidence of the evils of the United States, some Russians are responding by asking why they can't do the same thing Stone did.

To the extent that such questions continue to echo through the Russian elite, that could easily mean that the greatest political contribution Oliver Stone will have made with his latest film is not to the people of the United States but to the people of Russia, who by asking the questions his movie has provoked may take steps that will change their country for the better.
 
    Trüki   E-post   FB     
23 Jan 2018 19:46
Eesti Rahvuskaaslaste programm
23 Jan 2018 18:03
Selgus 2019. aasta laulu- ja tantsupeo juhtmõte XXVII üldlaulupidu ja XX tantsupidu toimuvad 2019. aasta 5.-7. juulini PM
23 Jan 2018 17:54
Eesti Põhiseaduskomisjoni enamus hülgas vabadussõjalaste au taastamise idee seadusesse raiumise UU
23 Jan 2018 11:30
Kuigi Californias on kanep legaalne, võivad suitsetavad turistid eluaegse Ameerikasse sisenemise keelu saada PM
23 Jan 2018 09:58
Washingtonis avatakse Eesti jaoks väga oluline näitus Vaatamata USA valitusasutuste tööseisakule toimub kõik plaanipäraselt
23 Jan 2018 05:00
In Putin, Russians Thought They Were Getting a Stierlitz But They May Have Gotten a Hitler Instead, Eidman Says (2)
23 Jan 2018 04:57
Militarily, Baltic Region is Stable; But in Terms of Information War, It’s Not, Latvian Expert Says
22 Jan 2018 21:53
Noorte kõnekonkursil “Kirjuta Eestile” osalemiseks on jäänud nädal
22 Jan 2018 10:35
Juhiseid sõja puhuks hakkab jagama ka Eesti ERR
22 Jan 2018 08:34
Public consultation Tue Jan 23 @ 6:30 re: Whistler's and Salvation Army sites
21 Jan 2018 18:42
Estonia’s centennial year 2018 Estonian Life
21 Jan 2018 17:17
“Räägime asjast” 21.01.2018 by Raadiosaade "Räägime asjast"
21 Jan 2018 16:54
KATRIN LUSTI BLOGI | Kas president peaks tagasi astuma?
21 Jan 2018 16:44
Rain Lõhmus: inimestel on hästi vale kontseptsioon, et raha kasvab DELFI
21 Jan 2018 16:32
Kutse Eesti Keskuse infosessioonidele Eesti Elu (13)
21 Jan 2018 16:27
Juhtkiri 3 2018 Tiigrit taltsutades Eesti Elu
21 Jan 2018 12:11
Kaju: Eesti on väga lähedal valitsuskriisile ERR
21 Jan 2018 12:05
Mis maksab see eesti naine? Eesti Elu (1)
SÜNDMUSED LÄHIAJAL
Jan 31 2018 - Toronto Eesti Maja
Eesti Keskuse projekti koosolek
Feb 21 2018 - Toronto Eesti Maja
Eesti Keskuse projekti koosolek

Vaata veel ...

Lisa uus sündmus