Eesti Elu
History: The past as a weapon in the present
Arvamus 22 Jul 2011  Eesti Elu
    Trüki   E-post   FB     
George Orwell put it aptly in “1984”: “He who controls the past controls the future. He who controls the present controls the past.”

No, it’s not just a catchy use of words. It has very definite purport. In 2009 Russian president Dmitry Medvedev ordered the creation of a government body mandated to deal directly with the past: the Presidential Commission for Prevention of Falsification of History to the Prejudice of Russia’s Interests - in essence a watchdog to guard against any diversion from the official line.

Appointed to the commission was Medvedev’s chief of staff, former and current Duma members, officials of the armed forces and security services. According to a Russian historian of international reputation, of the 28 members, only three were historians, none of whom had a reputation among professional historians.

Critics have said that the group is “dominated by state functionaries, and scholars are conspicuous by their minimal presence. … This balance between scholars and chinovniki leaves little doubt about what the Commission will set out to do.”

Following the collapse of the Soviet Union, nations previously under Moscow’s domination began to reassess the version of history forced upon them buy the Soviet Union. Russia became concerned and deemed it vital, for instance “to protect history and the heroic deeds of our fathers and grandfathers” in World War II. It wasn’t necessary to “politicise” history in the manner of countries like Lithuania and Latvia the Commission indicated. But legislation aimed at “Countering the Rehabilitation of Nazism, Nazi Criminals and Their Accomplices in New Independent States on the Territory of the Former USSR” was appropriately drafted, the goal was to prevent the tarnishing of Russia’s international reputation and Russia’s “near abroad” was targeted. Who else would want to make some major adjustments in the Soviet-era official record but those country who were forced to live a lie for 50 years.

Historians note that the language the Kremlin employs in explaining the problem reminds one of the Stalin-era vernacular: “Medvedev’s language is sadly reminiscent of Soviet-era history journals and their regular attacks on ‘bourgeois falsifiers’. … In 1931 Stalin dismissed historians as ‘archives rats’, and we’ve generally taken pride in that label. Though Medvedev is no Stalinist, he’s pandering to similar sentiments.”

Other observers have given reasonable explanation for the motives of the commission: Government officials have long wanted the Criminal Code to provide the legal opportunity to arrest and convict the regime’s critics for their opinions and statements. This follows Stalin’s scheme whereby he created the 58th clause of the criminal code on ‘counterrevolutionary activity. Those found guilty of ‘agitation and propaganda’ would be prosecuted.

The 70th and 190th clauses of the Brezhnev-era’s criminal code provided confinement in psychiatric institutions for individuals found guilty of ‘anti-Soviet agitation and propaganda’ and ‘slanderous fabrications that discredited the Soviet system’.

Vladimir Ryzhkov, a former State Duma deputy is blunt in his assessment of the Commission’s raison d’etre: “The irony in this farce is that the worst falsifiers of history have by far been Russian and Soviet authorities. [The Commission] creates a direct threat to historians and ordinary citizens trying to research the history of the war objectively.”

(To be cont’d.)
    Trüki   E-post   FB     
23 Jan 2018 19:46
Eesti Rahvuskaaslaste programm
23 Jan 2018 18:03
Selgus 2019. aasta laulu- ja tantsupeo juhtmõte XXVII üldlaulupidu ja XX tantsupidu toimuvad 2019. aasta 5.-7. juulini PM
23 Jan 2018 17:54
Eesti Põhiseaduskomisjoni enamus hülgas vabadussõjalaste au taastamise idee seadusesse raiumise UU
23 Jan 2018 11:30
Kuigi Californias on kanep legaalne, võivad suitsetavad turistid eluaegse Ameerikasse sisenemise keelu saada PM
23 Jan 2018 09:58
Washingtonis avatakse Eesti jaoks väga oluline näitus Vaatamata USA valitusasutuste tööseisakule toimub kõik plaanipäraselt
23 Jan 2018 05:00
In Putin, Russians Thought They Were Getting a Stierlitz But They May Have Gotten a Hitler Instead, Eidman Says (2)
23 Jan 2018 04:57
Militarily, Baltic Region is Stable; But in Terms of Information War, It’s Not, Latvian Expert Says
22 Jan 2018 21:53
Noorte kõnekonkursil “Kirjuta Eestile” osalemiseks on jäänud nädal
22 Jan 2018 10:35
Juhiseid sõja puhuks hakkab jagama ka Eesti ERR
22 Jan 2018 08:34
Public consultation Tue Jan 23 @ 6:30 re: Whistler's and Salvation Army sites
21 Jan 2018 18:42
Estonia’s centennial year 2018 Estonian Life
21 Jan 2018 17:17
“Räägime asjast” 21.01.2018 by Raadiosaade "Räägime asjast"
21 Jan 2018 16:54
KATRIN LUSTI BLOGI | Kas president peaks tagasi astuma?
21 Jan 2018 16:44
Rain Lõhmus: inimestel on hästi vale kontseptsioon, et raha kasvab DELFI
21 Jan 2018 16:32
Kutse Eesti Keskuse infosessioonidele Eesti Elu (14)
21 Jan 2018 16:27
Juhtkiri 3 2018 Tiigrit taltsutades Eesti Elu
21 Jan 2018 12:11
Kaju: Eesti on väga lähedal valitsuskriisile ERR
21 Jan 2018 12:05
Mis maksab see eesti naine? Eesti Elu (1)
Jan 31 2018 - Toronto Eesti Maja
Eesti Keskuse projekti koosolek
Feb 21 2018 - Toronto Eesti Maja
Eesti Keskuse projekti koosolek

Vaata veel ...

Lisa uus sündmus