Eesti Elu
Estonian as an example for spelling in English
Arvamus 05 Jul 2012  Eesti Elu
    Trüki   E-post   FB     
To the beginner, the English language’s sights and sounds often don’t jibe. Rough, dough, doe, mow, now, roe (fish egg), row (with oar). Oar, or. Some, sum. Why, nigh. Glue, do. To, two. Corpse, corps, horse, worse. Tear (in eye), tear (rip). Sew, so. Brake, break, bleak. Daughter, laughter, rafter. Doll, roll. Some, home. The list is practically endless.

Allan Kiisk has been on a mission of orthographic reform for years. With the recent publication of his second book, Simpel-Fonetik Dictionary (Tate Publishing), Kiisk wants to eliminate the frustration for beginners caused by English spelling. “English is becoming a global language. I want to make it easier to learn. I support the global use of English.”

His first book on the subject was released several years ago. Simple Phonetic English Spelling – Introduction to Simpel-Fonetik, the Single-Sound-per-Letter Writing Method (Tate Publishing) established the rules of logical spelling: a) Each letter represents only one spoken sound; b) For longer vowels and stronger consonants use double letters – and another letter with the same sound. The same rules could easily apply for the Estonian language.

The new alphabet would add the letters ä and ö, and eliminate the letters c,q, x, y – adding up to a total of 24. Why pick ä and ö? (The bane of Hiidlased and Saarlased – õ.)The letter A in current English is used to represent more than eleven different sounds. Examples: far, ant, all, ago, make, head, read, foam, fear, pair, earn. C, q, x, and y are eliminated because they’re not suitable for Simpel-Fonetik writing. Each represents more than one sound and can be substituted by other, more common letters.

Wen ju riid Simpel-Fonetik words, ju mast pei ättenshön to iitsh leter. Rimember, iitsh leter häs oolweis the seim saund, the saund given in the Simpel-Fonetik alphabet, regardless wat leter is nekst tu it.

Kiisk says that Simpel-Fonetik is based on the keep-it-simple principle. It has only one letter for the sound of R, and it uses TH for both the slightly different pronounciations of that sound, as in then and three, because most people, especially foreigners, have difficulties pronouncing the Englis R and TH as it is. One must take into account that there are now at least three times more foreign than native speakers of English.


Allan Kiisk spent his tshaildhud in Estonia änd tiineidsh jeers in Germany bifor kaming tu the United States. Hi obteind his elektrikal endshiniiring edukeishon ät Oregon State änd Stanford *Universitys. Hi worked äs än endshineer änd mänidsher for the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, äs ä professor of endshiniiring ät the University of Redlands, California, änd äs the prinsipal endshiniir in his oun konsalting förm, Alkitek Associates. Hi änd his waif, Karin, häv träveld änd livd in meni kantris. Thei häv setld daun nier Sacramento, California, klous tu their tshildren.

Since 1850 simple phonetic writing has been the rule in Estonia, in Finland much before that. It has been an ideal method of writing ever since. Neither the Finns nor Estonians need to spend time learning pronounciation or spelling. No need to look up the spelling of words in dictionaries. They do it mainly for foreign words and mostly for those originating in the English language.

Kiisk’s solution for difficult and sometimes illogical rules of the English language has been a quest of many international prominents. None other than John Milton, Samuel Johnson, Charles Dickens, Mark Twain, H.G.Wells, Isaac Asimov, George Bernard Shaw, Charles Darwin, Benjamin Franklin, Noah Webster (yes, of dictionary fame) Theodore Roosevelt have all thrown their hat into the ring, have proposed English language orthographic reform. But the advocacy of these, and other influential and credible luminaries has not created a mass movement. Why would Kiisk expect otherwise?

Kiisk explains: Other proposals have been more complicated, difficult to learn. They haven’t considered the case of the enormous proportion of foreigners who speak English, it’s global reach and the blending with other languages. The letters and sounds used in Simpel-Fonetik conform with the International (NATO) Alphabet. They also conform with the International Phonetic Alphabet, practically in its entirety. That’s only part of the explanation for Kiisk’s optimism.

It would be naïve to suggest that Kiisk’s Estonian roots, the acknowledged national characteristics of perserverance and obstinacy will prevail in Kiisk’s pursuit. At the very least, a logical, easy to adapt orthographic reform is another innovation offered by an Estonian. Gud lak tu him.
Laas Leivat
 
    Trüki   E-post   FB     
26 May 2016 12:16
Why the standoff between the U.S. and Russia is here to stay
26 May 2016 12:08
Minister of Defence Hanso: NATO’s “open door policy” will continue
26 May 2016 12:04
Talk of CIA Black Site in Lithuania Resurfaces
26 May 2016 12:01
E-residency in Estonia Hits a Milestone
26 May 2016 11:22
EELK nõuab riigilt Niguliste kiriku eest 37 miljonit eurot PM
26 May 2016 10:00
Rootsi pealinna koolis hoitakse juba üle 70 aasta au sees eesti keelt ja kultuuri. Kui hästi oskavad lapsed emakeelt? TV3 VIDEO
26 May 2016 09:42
Murepöördumine seoses arengutega Tallinna lauluväljakul
25 May 2016 19:17
Üleilmakool kutsub väljaspool Eestit elavaid 5.-9. klassi õpilasi õppima e-kursustel.
25 May 2016 17:07
President Ilves Stanfordi Ülikoolis: Euroopa Liidu möödunud kriisid on pisipeavalu võrreldes tänastega
25 May 2016 16:49
Euroopa vabatahtlikud muinsuskaitsjad kogunevad Madriidis Europa Nostra aastakongressil
25 May 2016 15:50
PRESS RELEASE Plácido Domingo and EU Commissioner Navracsics announce Grand Prix winners of the European Heritage Awards 2016 in Madrid
25 May 2016 10:22
TALLINNA TEADLASTE MAJA OKUPATSIOONIDE MUUSEUMIST (1)
25 May 2016 09:48
Otsepilt merikotkapesalt (1)
24 May 2016 18:33
Einar Laigna: me kas oleme võimelised veel üheks renessanssiks, või me hukkume Objektiiv
24 May 2016 18:06
Nopri talu peremees: kütuseaktsiisi tõus on selge signaal – maalt ära! ERR
24 May 2016 17:55
VIDEOD | Eestlased Kanadas: see on nagu maailmalõpp, inimesed on paaniliselt põgenenud Õhtuleht
23 May 2016 17:08
E.E.L.K. Sinod Torontos. Teeme juttu piiskop electus Thomas Vagaga
23 May 2016 16:01
Nädala portree # 20 Eesti Elu
SÜNDMUSED LÄHIAJAL

Vaata veel ...

Lisa uus sündmus